Catalysis Argonne

Advanced Photon SourceIn Elemental Discoveries this month, X-rays reveal the inner secrets of the world around us as seen under the illumination of ANL's Advanced Photon Source. David Bradley is currently working with Argonne National Laboratory on a series of articles for the annual report of the ANL's Advanced Photon Source. For the latest issue of Elemental Discoveries, I will be offering a preview of the advanced science featured in the report.


Are films ferroelectric? | Gold nanocrystals | Photosynthetic system | Dissecting the atom | SAXS and the water channel | Digging in the dirt | Folding Protein Sensors | X-ray movies

Catalytic clues from octahedral tilt

The smallest of structural changes can lead to significant effects on the properties of technologically important materials. Take perovskites, for instance. The perovskite structure is an archetypal crystal structure found in a diverse range of minerals, including materials with useful catalytic and electronic properties. But, subtle distortions from the archetypal structure can turn an active catalyst into an inactive one or a useful superconducting material into an insulator.

Now, Clare Grey, Peter Chupas and their colleagues at the State University of New York at Stony Brook, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Michigan State University, and Argonne National Laboratory have used high-energy x-rays from the 1-ID beamline at the Advanced Photon Source to study the structure-dependent properties of the perovskite-related mineral a-aluminum trifluoride (a-AlF3). Their findings show how new x-ray diffraction methods can allow subtle changes in structure to be detected and modeled more accurately than before.

a-AlF3 is commonly used in the chemical industry as a catalyst for fluorocarbon manufacture and as an additive for improving the electrolysis of aluminum ore in aluminum production. The material has a distorted perovskite structure related to the compound rhenium oxide at room temperature. However, heat it above 468 Celsius and the material changes, adopting the cubic rhenium oxide structure.

According to the team, using conventional approaches, such as powder diffraction and neutron diffraction, to analyze this phase change does not provide enough detailed information as to how the change occurs. Instead, such techniques yield useful long-range information that is averaged out and so cannot reveal the dynamics of the process. By necessity, it is the movement of ions or atoms that underlies the structural change. Now, the team has obtained data from the 1-ID beamline that is detailed enough to reveal the dynamics of such structure-changing processes.

Previous researchers explained the structural changes in perovskites and other minerals in terms of the rotation of rigid octahedral sub-units in the crystal structure. Indeed, scientists use the rigid unit model with great success to describe the phase changes in silica and various natural perovskites. In the case of aluminum trifluoride, these octahedra comprise a central aluminum atom surrounded by six fluorine atoms, one at each vertex of the octahedron. By combining two distinct techniques - so-called Rietveld refinement and a pair distribution function (PDF) - Grey, Chupas, and their colleagues, could observe the shifting octahedra within the material's structure at temperatures just below the phase change, at the temperature at which it occurs, and just above it.

The team has also run molecular dynamics simulations in parallel with their refinement of the beamline data. The simulations gave them a way to "animate" the phase transition as one form of aluminum trifluoride is converted into the other with increasing temperature. The simulations then allowed the researchers to refine their model still further by comparing the simulation with their experimental results.

The study shows that the high-temperature structure of aluminum trifluoride is highly dynamic and is essentially composed of a superposition of tilted "AlF3" octahedra that rotate between the different tilted structures, leading to an apparent cubic, undistorted structure.

The researchers now hope to extend their approach to other materials such as other perovskites and catalysts such as cerium dioxide, negative thermal expansion materials, such as zirconium molybdate, and perovskite minerals of geological relevance. One such mineral, magnesium silicate, comprises the bulk of the earth's mantle and is the subject of investigations to explain anomalous seismic behaviour observed at the boundary between the mantle and the earth's core. The researchers anticipate that the combined experimental approach, where both local atomic structure and long-range structure are probed, will provide valuable insight into how local structural distortions couple with physical properties or reactivity in this and other related mineral structures.

See: Peter J. Chupas,1,5 Santanu Chaudhuri,1 Jonathan C. Hanson,2 Xiangyun Qiu,3 Peter L. Lee,4 Sarvjit D. Shastri,4 Simon J. L. Billinge,3 and Clare P. Grey,1 "Probing Local and Long-Range Structure Simultaneously: An In Situ Study of the High-Temperature Phase Transition of a-AlF3," J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 4256-2257 (2004).

Additional reference: Santanu Chaudhuri, Peter J. Chupas, Mark Wilson, Paul Madden, Clare P. Grey, J. Phys. Chem. B. 108, 3437-3445 (2004).

In Issue 76
Are films ferroelectric?
Discipline for gold nanocrystals
X-rays shed light on machinery of photosynthesis

Back to the January elemental discoveries index page